In the Coen Brothers’ dark comedy masterpiece Barton Fink, John Turturro’s writer character is tasked with scripting a boxing film for a Hollywood studio. He wants the film to be an exploration of the mind and pain. He states ‘there’s no road map for that kinda territory, and exploring it can be painful ‘. However in the climax of the film, Turturro is chastised by the studio head for writing ‘a fruity movie about suffering’ and is essentially banished from Hollywood. I mention this because oddly enough the strongest elements of Southpaw are the moments of ‘fruity suffering’. However, these are only briefly touched upon because the film is more concerned with a more standard tale of an underdog.
Jake Gyllenhaal plays Billy Hope (Hope, get it?), a World Light Heavyweight champion boxer. He has the perfect wife (Rachel McAdams), and daughter (Oona Laurence). He and his wife were raised in social care together and boxing got him through the toughest years of his life. Boxing is a way for Billy to channel his inner fury into something legal and inspiring. However, tragedy strikes and Hope loses everything, his riches, his house, custody of his daughter and his respect and is forced to work his way back to the top from the bottom. The film is slightly different to other rags to riches boxing films such as Rocky, The Fighter or Warrior in the sense that Southpaw is riches to rags to riches. Kurt Sutter’s screenplay at its strongest is the moments in which Hope’s life fall apart. Sutter captures an existential angst and it helps that Gyllenhaal and Laurence’s performances are strong enough to distill this anger. The story was originally conceived with Eminem in mind to star. This makes sense due to the ferocity of his rapping and the well-publicised relationship between himself and his daughter.
There’s a long stretch of Southpaw where there is no boxing and it almost becomes a melodrama. These moments are also very effective. Hope fears his daughter will be raised through the system, just as he was, which adds a nicely cyclical quality to the narrative as well as providing a lot of dramatic tension throughout the film. In order to provide for his daughter, he is forced to find employment training young orphans to box. However, all this drama (along with logic) go out the window, when Hope is offered the chance to fight for his title back. This doesn’t make sense because Hope’s agent (a bland 50 Cent) had told him that he was not allowed fight for a year because of a suspension Hope received. However, halfway through the film, Fiddy reappears and states that he knows people who can get Hope’s suspension lifted. Why didn’t he speak up earlier about that? After this point the film loses what made it unique and becomes an enjoyable but generic boxing movie, hitting the same dramatic beats of the countless boxing films before it. Also a sub-plot regarding a child Hope is training is handled woefully. Without going into too much detail, the storyline of the child and his suffering serves only to demonstrate that Hope can bond with his tough-as-nails trainer (a well-cast Forrest Whittaker). Another bewildering mis-step is that Naomie Harris (28 Days Later, Skyfall) is cast as Hope’s daughter’s social care worker and is given literally nothing to do. Harris is a wonderful actress and to see her wasted like this is disappointing.
Gyllenhall is becoming the new De Niro in the way he physically transforms himself for each role. He looks and sounds utterly convincing as a boxer, which is especially impressive since this film follows his role as Lou Bloom in Nightcrawler – a film where he appears to be just skin and bone. Antione Fuqua (Training Day, The Equalizer) directs the scenes in the ring with great panache, employing every stylistic choice from POV shots to dutch camera angles to slow motion shots in order to convey the chaotic nature of the sport. Rachel McAdams adds real heart, charm and depth to a role whose only real purpose is as a way to sympathise with Hope. I would advise people to avoid trailers for Southpaw as they reveal far too much detail regarding plot and twists.
The bones are there for Southpaw to become the new classic sports movie a la Rocky, perhaps another draft of the script would have caused the film to reach its true potential. As it stands Southpaw is just good, solid entertainment anchored by strong performances by Gyllenhall, McAdams, Whittaker and Laurence. It’s a pity that the film is just not as brilliant as its central lead.
Verdict 3/4
If you’ve seen more than one other boxing film Southpaw will be solid but generic entertainment. If you haven’t this will probably be your new favourite film.